Home
Images
Downloads
Resources
Forums
Register
Log in

Follow railwayscene on Twitter
Home -> Forums -> Train Operating Companies -> Southern -> Gatwick Express 460's going to different TOC?:

Post reply

Gatwick Express 460's going to different TOC?
11:55, 08 February 2010:Report | Quote
NeilA
Member

Send a message

Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 121
Hi, read this article last week and was wondering if the 460's go then what will replace them? 377/5's?

http://www.southernelectric.org.uk/tocnews/gex460news.html

Neil,
London
12:30, 08 February 2010:Report | Quote
Paul Scott
Member

Send a message

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2375
Originally posted by NeilA:
Hi, read this article last week and was wondering if the 460's go then what will replace them? 377/5's?

http://www.southernelectric.org.uk/tocnews/gex460news.html

Neil,
London


They won't be replaced as such, the 442s that currently run the peak services will just run GatEx all day instead, from Dec 2010.

Paul


Number of edits: 1. Last edit: 12:32, 08 February 2010
18:27, 08 February 2010:Report | Quote
L E Greys
Member

Send a message

Joined: Oct 2008
Posts: 428
It's my understanding that they're going to be split up as well, and used to reinforce the JOPs. I can understand how that might work with the middle vehicles, but the driving cars might be a bit of a problem. Presumably they'll take the nose off and reduce each unit to five cars, but that still leaves the luggage vans with no seats in them. Any idea what will happen to them?
20:02, 08 February 2010:Report | Quote
Paul Scott
Member

Send a message

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2375
Originally posted by L E Greys:
It's my understanding that they're going to be split up as well, and used to reinforce the JOPs. I can understand how that might work with the middle vehicles, but the driving cars might be a bit of a problem. Presumably they'll take the nose off and reduce each unit to five cars, but that still leaves the luggage vans with no seats in them. Any idea what will happen to them?


According to Modern Railway's Tony Miles, posted in uk.railway:

AIUI - the Class 460 fleet has 16 driving cars and 48 "non-driving".

The plan is to increase 24 of the 30 458s to 5-cars (leaving 24 "non-
driving" from the 460s).

AND to create an additional 6 5-car sets from the 460s - leaving 10
vehicles (4 driving and 6 non-driving) which will be robbed for spares
as many of the components are no longer available.

All cab ends to be replaced with something that looks like a Desiro so
all 30 5-car and 6 4-car sets will look very similar to Desiros.

The desks are the same on 458 and 460 sets and once the ends are
replaced they (apparently) will all look and feel the same.

Lots of internal refurbs and of course 4 Class 460 driving cars will
need to be fitted with windows and seats as they are currently just
luggage vans.


Having said that, it is still only a proposal, but it seems likely as other wise the 64 carriages would all be doing nothing this time next year...

Edited as eventually I found Tony's original post - in the middle of a thread about 313s...

Paul


Number of edits: 1. Last edit: 20:12, 08 February 2010
22:45, 08 February 2010:Report | Quote
darky
Member

Send a message

Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1913
Doesnt it seem crazy that some 460 vehichles will be used as Christmas trees
13:18, 09 February 2010:Report | Quote
Paul Scott
Member

Send a message

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2375
I think it might be partly to do with the total number of motor bogies needed. I'm fairly sure there is also a complex set of changes to be made regarding the proportion of motor coaches in the resulting 5 car units.

I think if all coaches could be used they wouldn't be retaining the six four car 458 units. [It is rumoured that these will be dedicated to the Guildford - Ascot service.]

Paul
21:22, 12 February 2010:Report | Quote
robshipway
Member


Send a message

Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 337
I can imagine that even that the class 460 trains will go off lease in December, that over refurbishment work that they probably will not be back in service until the May 2011 timetable at the earliest working on the SWT lines?
22:22, 12 February 2010:Report | Quote
Paul Scott
Member

Send a message

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2375
Originally posted by robshipway:
I can imagine that even that the class 460 trains will go off lease in December, that over refurbishment work that they probably will not be back in service until the May 2011 timetable at the earliest working on the SWT lines?


Probably not, but NR have still got to do a whole load of platform lengthening anyway before the lengthened trains are useful.

You may or may not have seen that there has been an announcement by NR starting the Central division platform lengthening, the South West area is yet to be mentioned outside the CP4 enhancement plan, although the timescales are supposed to be similar.

Paul
21:01, 21 February 2010:Report | Quote
Rob
Member


Send a message

Joined: May 2005
Posts: 386
Hi everyone, sorry to have to ask a basic question, but are the 460s *definitely* destined for SWT. There seems to be some suggestions based upon the idea that they will and be merged with the 458s. Others suggest that there is simply a new build of desiros to replace the 458s?!

Thanks
09:46, 22 February 2010:Report | Quote
Paul Scott
Member

Send a message

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2375
Originally posted by Rob:
Hi everyone, sorry to have to ask a basic question, but are the 460s *definitely* destined for SWT. There seems to be some suggestions based upon the idea that they will and be merged with the 458s. Others suggest that there is simply a new build of desiros to replace the 458s?!

Thanks


The only official info is that they are definitely off lease with SN by December this year, and they will then be used to strengthen services on 'another route'. This is confirmed in the Sussex RUS, which states it wasn't mentioned in the earlier draft due to confidentiality. Use with SWT is not officially confirmed anywhere I can find, but there isn't much of a choice for future use of DC only units really.

SWT are supposed to get 140 extra carriages for 10 car inner suburban (Windsor side and main line side) services, the 458/460 proposals don't even provide half that requirement, so there could probably need to be a Desiro order as well. I don't think there has been any realistic suggestions that the 458s will be replaced though. Firstly, where could they go? Also, why would DfT allow SWT to sign up to the full additional quantity they need plus 120 more cars to replace the 458s as well?

There are also regular rumours that the 456s (24 x 2 car) will be transferred to SWT, but again, that doesn't provide enough stock, if the idea is to run them in multiple with 455s. However there have been experiments with running 455s in 3+3+4 formations.

Paul


Number of edits: 1. Last edit: 11:42, 22 February 2010
22:41, 08 March 2010:Report | Quote
poooooky
Member

Send a message

Joined: Apr 2007
Posts: 14
I assume they won't use 10car's everywhere as platforms 1-4 at Waterloo which are predominantly 455 users are only able to take 8car units. Unless there are plans to alter the platforms / track layout here?

john
08:52, 09 March 2010:Report | Quote
Mark B!
Member

Send a message

Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1229
News credits: 1
Long Term there is with a new concourse in the undercroft and the tracks extended over the existing concourse
10:58, 09 March 2010:Report | Quote
Paul Scott
Member

Send a message

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2375
Platform 1 and 2 will be closed by Dec 2013, with all normal operations moving over by two platforms, and all pointwork and signalling altered to replicate existing functionality. In other words trains that currently use 1-4 will use 3-6, etc etc repeated across the station. This allows platform 3 and 4 to be extended to 10 car.

Having followed all the NR statements over the last few years I think this generally supersedes the extension of platforms across the concourse. There should be movement on this project shortly, as back in December the enhancements plan reckoned that the single option chosen would be confirmed by then.

Paul
12:14, 09 March 2010:Report | Quote
d.river
Member

Send a message

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 462
Originally posted by Paul Scott:
Originally posted by Rob:
Hi everyone, sorry to have to ask a basic question, but are the 460s *definitely* destined for SWT. There seems to be some suggestions based upon the idea that they will and be merged with the 458s. Others suggest that there is simply a new build of desiros to replace the 458s?!

Thanks


The only official info is that they are definitely off lease with SN by December this year, and they will then be used to strengthen services on 'another route'. This is confirmed in the Sussex RUS, which states it wasn't mentioned in the earlier draft due to confidentiality. Use with SWT is not officially confirmed anywhere I can find, but there isn't much of a choice for future use of DC only units really.

SWT are supposed to get 140 extra carriages for 10 car inner suburban (Windsor side and main line side) services, the 458/460 proposals don't even provide half that requirement, so there could probably need to be a Desiro order as well. I don't think there has been any realistic suggestions that the 458s will be replaced though. Firstly, where could they go? Also, why would DfT allow SWT to sign up to the full additional quantity they need plus 120 more cars to replace the 458s as well?

There are also regular rumours that the 456s (24 x 2 car) will be transferred to SWT, but again, that doesn't provide enough stock, if the idea is to run them in multiple with 455s. However there have been experiments with running 455s in 3+3+4 formations.

Paul


i think the 456 rumours may have some legs this time. they are nearing the end of their lease with southern...
12:40, 09 March 2010:Report | Quote
Paul Scott
Member

Send a message

Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2375
Originally posted by d.river:
Originally posted by Paul Scott:


There are also regular rumours that the 456s (24 x 2 car) will be transferred to SWT, but again, that doesn't provide enough stock, if the idea is to run them in multiple with 455s. However there have been experiments with running 455s in 3+3+4 formations.

Paul


i think the 456 rumours may have some legs this time. they are nearing the end of their lease with southern...


I don't doubt they could move. What I'm thinking of though is that if you take the existing 455 fleet of around 90 x 4 car units, which are effectively 45 x 8 car trains on weekdays, 24 x 2 car units isn't enough to extend them all to 10 car. Then without gangway connections, SDO isn't practical (assuming the 455s can be fitted - this is still under consideration for some stations where platforms cannot be lengthened). Would they not be better off with the 508s as well?

Paul
10:39, 11 March 2010:Report | Quote
d.river
Member

Send a message

Joined: Feb 2006
Posts: 462
Originally posted by Paul Scott:
Originally posted by d.river:
[quote]Originally posted by Paul Scott:


There are also regular rumours that the 456s (24 x 2 car) will be transferred to SWT, but again, that doesn't provide enough stock, if the idea is to run them in multiple with 455s. However there have been experiments with running 455s in 3+3+4 formations.

Paul


i think the 456 rumours may have some legs this time. they are nearing the end of their lease with southern...


I don't doubt they could move. What I'm thinking of though is that if you take the existing 455 fleet of around 90 x 4 car units, which are effectively 45 x 8 car trains on weekdays, 24 x 2 car units isn't enough to extend them all to 10 car. Then without gangway connections, SDO isn't practical (assuming the 455s can be fitted - this is still under consideration for some stations where platforms cannot be lengthened). Would they not be better off with the 508s as well?

Paul[/quote]
on the southern side of things i have heard that although most metro stns will be extended to 10 car, in the foreseeable future, southern will run max. of 9 car trains when the 377/3come up from BI (obviously 3x377/3) because of the 455/456 sdo issue..add to that southern will have extra stock as the 442s will run all brighton expresses making 377s surplus, and the same with the 313s....this together with the running out of the 456 lease may mean southern are getting rid of them to swt.
Post reply

This thread has been read 1334 times